Starfish Shack's Reviews

16 aggregated reviews
Review Summary
Star 16 aggregated reviews
5 stars
16
100%
4 stars
0
0%
3 stars
0
0%
2 stars
0
0%
1 star
0
0%
Review Score by Booking Channel
Star 16 aggregated reviews
OTA logo
vrbo
5.00
(16)

Guest Reviews for Starfish Shack

Vrbo logo

John C.Stayed in Starfish Shack

Property managed by Lizzie Lu's Island Retreat
Mar 2026

The accommodations were awsome. Great location. Having the private pool was perfect, especially having a fur baby. She was able to hang out with us the whole time. We would definitely stay here again.

Vrbo logo

Katrine J.Stayed in Starfish Shack

Property managed by Lizzie Lu's Island Retreat
Jul 2024

Excellent stay!

We really enjoyed this home. It was the perfect size for our family of 3, nicely updated and super clean.It felt very much like a home away from home. We had everything we needed. Comfortable beds, nice sheets and towels and a kitchen stocked with most essentials. Located well in a residential area, which I really liked, but right around the corner from the beautiful beach.Management was very attentive and responded right away to answer any questions. We really enjoyed our Gem cart, which was in the garage upon arrival. It was fun to explore the island. I was very impressed with how Lizzy Lu’s does business! You can tell they really care about their properties and the guest experience. Pool and patio area was very tropical and cozy.

Vrbo logo

Viaggiatore verificatoStayed in Starfish Shack

Property managed by Lizzie Lu's Island Retreat
Jun 2023

Starfish Shack

Everything but an ocean view. Property very clean and well maintained.

Vrbo logo

Lori M.Stayed in Starfish Shack

Property managed by Lizzie Lu's Island Retreat
Oct 2022

We loved the Starfish Shack

We had a great time. The house was perfect for our vacation. A easy walk to the beach. We will definitely be back.

Vrbo logo

Angie S.Stayed in Starfish Shack

Property managed by Lizzie Lu's Island Retreat
Aug 2022

Week of relaxation

This property was absolutely perfect! The host was more than helpful. The small touches everywhere made our stay comfortable. Loved the private pool with the tranquil backyard setting. Kitchen had everything we needed to cook meals and save on eating out. Will definitely book with this host again.