Naughty Dog Island's Reviews

288 aggregated reviews
Review Summary
Star 288 aggregated reviews
5 stars
282
98%
4 stars
6
2%
3 stars
0
0%
2 stars
0
0%
1 star
0
0%
Review Score by Booking Channel
Star 288 aggregated reviews
OTA logo
airbnb
4.98
(274)
OTA logo
vrbo
4.91
(11)
OTA logo
booking
5.00
(3)

Guest Reviews for Naughty Dog Island

Airbnb logo

JenniferStayed in Naughty Dog Island

Property managed by One Big Sustainable Island
30 Aug 2026

This island is a perfect getaway to unwind and relax in nature. This was my favorite place we have ever stayed. Kent was a great host. This island adventure is truley a special place. We hope to come back one day.

Booking logo

SophiaStayed in Naughty Dog Island

Property managed by One Big Sustainable Island
24 Aug 2026

Amazing private island experience in a beautiful lake

amazing experience and great fishing! the island was comfortable and well equipped, and the host was wonderful. We enjoyed the thoughtful amenities around the island such as the swimming platform hammock, multiple seating areas, and off-grid power setup. The lake itself is a hidden gem: clean, quiet and amazing fishing - caught our personal best bass right off the dock!
highly recommend

Answer icon

Response

Sophia, thank you! We’re delighted you had such a great private island experience, but we have to admit that catching your personal-best bass right off the dock is going to be difficult for us to take credit for. Annabessacook Lake apparently decided to provide the deluxe welcome package. We’re especially glad you enjoyed the swimming platform, hammocks, seating areas, and off-grid power setup. Naughty Dog Island was designed to be a private island getaway in Maine where you can disappear into the lake for a few days without having to disappear entirely from civilization. And for anyone dreaming of a Maine fishing getaway, your review has now established a rather dangerous precedent: apparently the bass are expected to provide personal bests. Thanks for spending a few days of island life with us. We’d love to have you back!

Airbnb logo

RowanStayed in Naughty Dog Island

Property managed by One Big Sustainable Island
23 Aug 2026

One of the greatest experiences I have had with a stay! Even with the rain, it was worth it! Kent is incredibly on top of things, extremely friendly and accommodating, and the stay was spectacular! Worth every penny. We will be returning!

Answer icon

Response

Rowan, thank you! “One of the greatest experiences I have had with a stay” is going to keep us smiling for a while. We’re especially glad a little Maine rain didn’t get in the way of enjoying Naughty Dog Island. A private island stay in Maine does occasionally come with weather supplied directly by Maine, but apparently the island passed its rainy-day exam. Thank you for the wonderful words about the experience and the care that goes into it. Hearing “worth every penny” means a great deal to us. And we particularly like the part about returning. We’d love to have you back, perhaps with a little more sunshine next time!

Airbnb logo

MeghanStayed in Naughty Dog Island

Property managed by One Big Sustainable Island
22 Aug 2026

One of the most amazing trips we’ve been on. Extremely peaceful and private. There was so much to do and the water was beautiful. Our dog also LOVED it. We will definitely be returning!

Answer icon

Response

Meghan, thank you! “One of the most amazing trips we’ve been on” is a pretty wonderful thing to hear. We’re delighted you found Naughty Dog Island peaceful, private, and full of ways to enjoy the water. That’s exactly what we hope for from a dog-friendly lake vacation in Maine: plenty of adventure when you want it, plenty of quiet when you don’t, and an entire island for the four-legged member of the family to investigate. It sounds like Luna understood the assignment. Thanks for spending five days of island life with us. We love hearing that you’re already planning another trip, and we’ll be delighted to welcome the whole crew back to Naughty Dog Island!

Airbnb logo

AlecStayed in Naughty Dog Island

Property managed by One Big Sustainable Island
3 Aug 2026

Third year in a row, and each stay is better than the last! It’s perfect. Plus our dog think it’s the greatest place on earth (they’re right)

Answer icon

Response

Alec, three years in a row! At this point, we may have to stop calling you visitors and start considering you seasonal island residents. We love having you back at Naughty Dog Island, and hearing that each stay keeps getting better means a lot to us. As for your dog declaring it the greatest place on earth, we see no reason to question such an obviously unbiased and authoritative source. Thanks for making this dog-friendly Maine island getaway part of your summer tradition. We’ll look forward to year four!